Dead To Me – Chapter 3 – Inbox

At first, it was exactly what it pretended to be. A sterile, professional exchange conducted in the stark, unforgiving light of a computer screen. 

He sent the resume. I thanked him, my reply a carefully crafted masterpiece of formal gratitude. He sent interview tips, bullet points about the STAR method and the importance of researching the company’s recent quarterly earnings. 

I asked follow-up questions, each one more desperate than the last, about cover letters and networking etiquette and whether it was a career-ending move to admit you spent your summer reading vampire novels instead of getting a relevant internship.

He replied from work, usually during those strange daytime pockets when other people are busy pretending to be productive. 

His emails were clean, well-structured, and possessed a dry wit that sneaked up on you like a slow-acting poison. He’d answer my question with the precision of a surgeon, then add one line at the end that would make me laugh out loud in the silent hush of the university library, earning me dirty looks from people who were actually trying to learn things. 

*P.S. Whatever you do, don’t use a Comic Sans font. That’s not a tip, that’s a moral imperative.* Or *P.S. I once had a candidate tell me their greatest weakness was that they were ‘too passionate.’ I almost hired them on the spot just to see what would happen.*

I started checking my email too often. It became a nervous tic, a compulsive finger-tap on the refresh button that was less about waiting for a message and more about seeking a hit. The little notification icon on my phone became a source of constant, low-grade anxiety and exhilaration.

Then he did too.

I knew because the timestamps started changing.

 At first, his replies came between nine and five, Monday to Friday. Then they started appearing at seven in the evening. Then on a Saturday afternoon. 

Then, one Tuesday night around eleven, an email from him landed in my inbox with the subject line: *Re: The existential horror of entry-level positions*. 

The body of the email contained only a link to a video of a cat falling off a chair.

I knew the rhythm of his mornings. I knew he was a coffee snob but had a guilty-pleasure weakness for those terrible powdered donuts from the vending machine. I knew his boss was a man named Gary who communicated exclusively in cryptic, one-sentence emails that were impossible to decipher.

 He knew when I was avoiding work because my replies got longer and more philosophical, drifting off on tangents about the meaning of life and the inherent absurdity of trying to summarize your entire personality on a single sheet of paper.

He started calling me out on it. 

*You only write like this when you’re procrastinating,* he’d say, the observation delivered with such dry accuracy it felt like a gentle scolding.

And I’d write back, *You only notice because you like reading me.*

He didn’t answer for twenty minutes. Twenty minutes is a lifetime in email-flirtation purgatory. It’s just long enough for you to convince yourself you’ve massively misread the entire situation, that you’ve crossed a line, that he’s currently showing his coworkers your message and they’re all having a good laugh at your expense. 

I spent those twenty minutes re-reading my last message, analyzing every word, every comma, for hidden signs of desperation. I was about to send a follow-up message that was just a string of nonsensical emojis as a distraction tactic when his reply came.

It was just one word.

*Correct.*

I smiled at my screen like an absolute idiot. A dopey, uncontainable, face-splitting grin that made my cheeks hurt. 

I was in the library, surrounded by people, and I felt completely, utterly alone in my little bubble of joy. That was the beginning, really. Not the party. Not the resume. The moment we both stopped pretending we weren’t already leaning in, the moment the professional scaffolding fell away and revealed the simple, terrifying truth underneath: we liked each other.

 We *really* liked each other.

Somewhere in that first month, it stopped being about career advice and became about everything else. 

It was a slow, seamless migration, a quiet infiltration of my daily life. What he had for lunch. The ridiculous thing my professor wore to class. A rude customer at the cafe where I worked. His impossible manager, Gary. My bad mood. His bad coffee. My terrible sleep schedule. 

We started narrating our days to each other before they were even over, creating a shared reality that existed only in the blue-white glow of our screens.

And that was the dangerous part.

Nothing dramatic happened at first. No grand confession. No late-night declaration with a city skyline behind it. There was no moment of explosive clarity. Just repetition. Familiarity. That quiet, creeping intimacy of being the person someone updates without thinking. 

He became the first person I’d tell anything to, and I became the same for him. We were building something out of words, out of timestamps and digital breadcrumbs, and it was both exhilarating and terrifying.

After a month, I could already picture my day without his emails. I could imagine getting through a lecture, a shift at work, a lonely evening in my crappy apartment, all on my own.

I just didn’t want to.

Neither did he.

The subject lines of our emails started to change. 

They went from *Resume* and *Follow-up Questions* to *This sandwich is an insult to bread* and *I think Gary is a robot sent from the future to destroy my will to live*.

 We were no longer two people talking about jobs. We were two people talking about life. Our conversations became a refuge, a private space where we could be our truest, weirdest selves without fear of judgment.

I found myself saving his emails. Not in a creepy, stalkerish way.

 At least, that’s what I told myself. 

I just… didn’t delete them. I created a folder for them. A special folder. I told myself it was for organization, for easy reference if I ever needed to look up a specific piece of advice. But that was a lie. I was saving them because they were precious. They were evidence. They were the building blocks of something I was terrified to name but couldn’t bear to lose.

The emails became longer, more detailed, more personal. 

We started sharing small, insignificant secrets. I told him about the childhood fear I still had of the dark, specifically the fear that there was something under my bed waiting to grab my feet. He told me that he still slept with the same ratty, childhood stuffed bear – a wombat named Wombat – on nights when he felt particularly lonely or stressed.

I told him I was a curvy girl with freckles and a pointed nose and eyes that were always too wide, like I was perpetually surprised by the world. I sent him a terrible, poorly lit selfie I took in my bathroom mirror, my face half-obscured by my phone. I didn’t know why I did it. It was an impulse. A moment of reckless bravery.

He replied five minutes later. *I like your surprise face,* he wrote. *And your freckles. They look like a map. I’ve always been good at reading maps.*

My heart did a full-on gymnastics routine in my chest. It was the most direct, unambiguous compliment he had ever given me, and it landed with the force of a physical blow.

 It wasn’t about my resume or my potential or my future. It was about *me*. About my face. About the things I was most self-conscious about.

I was sitting in my tiny apartment, wearing my oldest, most comfortable sweatpants, eating a bowl of cereal for dinner, and I felt more seen than I had in my entire life. This man, this calm, steady, beautiful man who I had only met once, was looking at a picture of my ridiculous face and seeing a map. Something to be explored. Something to be cherished.

That was the moment I knew. It wasn’t a lightning strike. It wasn’t a sudden revelation. It was a quiet, settling certainty that settled deep in my bones. This was real. This was happening. And it was happening to me.

← Previous Chapter
Next Chapter →